Ernst & Young and Audit Clients Cut Lobbying Ties
Ernst & Young's lobbying unit is no longer listed as a lobbyist for three major U.S. companies, all of whom were 2011 audit clients of the accounting giant. The deregistration follows questions raised by two U.S. senators in March about whether the dual relationships crossed auditor independence boundaries. Documents filed last month with Congress showed that Washington Council Ernst & Young, the E&Y unit, was no longer registered as doing lobbying work for Amgen Inc., CVS Caremark Corp., and Verizon Communications Inc.
A lobbying-contract termination was also filed on March 31 for a fourth company, Nomura Holdings Inc., which, according to securities filings, uses an E&Y affiliate for auditing services. E&Y had provided lobbying services to Nomura since June 2011, according to papers on file with Congress.
Auditors that review corporations' books every year must follow rules limiting other ties with audit clients. The rules—meant to prevent auditors fr om getting too cozy with audit clients—were substantially beefed up a decade ago after a rash of accounting scandals at Enron Corp. and other companies.
An Ernst & Young spokesman declined to comment on the discontinued lobbying relationships. Officials with Nomura, Verizon and CVS declined to comment. Amgen officials could not immediately be reached for comment.
The chief accountant for the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, James Kroeker, speaking at a financial reporting conference at Baruch College in New York on Thursday, said SEC rules state an auditor should not act in an advocacy role for a company it audits and lobbying would be inconsistent with that.
Kroeker did not mention any audit firms by name.
He said: "If you think about lobbying in the traditional sense, you would say, 'wouldn't somebody that's lobbying be placing themselves in a position to be an advocate?'"
Asked whether the SEC was looking into E&Y's lobbying activities, an official in the agency's enforcement division declined to comment because its investigations are not public.
"We are aware of it and we are cognizant of what the rules are," said Howard Scheck, chief accountant of the SEC's division of enforcement, on the sidelines of Thursday's conference.
"If there's a violation that we find, we'll certainly do something about that," he said, without referring to E&Y.Reuters reported in March that Washington Council Ernst & Young had been hired as a lobbyist for a number of E&Y's audit clients, prompting two lawmakers to demand closer scrutiny.
Democratic Senators Carl Levin and Jack Reed both expressed concerns at the time and urged the SEC to look into the matter. On Thursday, Reed's office did not immediately respond to inquiries seeking comment. Levin's office declined to comment.
Verizon had a particularly long relationship with E&Y's lobbyists, who helped the telecommunications company with tax issues beginning in September 2001. The two other lobbying relationships were more recent, dating back to February in the case of Amgen and September in the case of CVS Caremark. Both contracts were connected to corporate tax debates.
The three U.S. terminations were all effective March 31 and Nomura's termination was filed the same day.
The E&Y spokesman referred Reuters to its earlier statement that Washington Council's work complied with independence rules.
The work was approved by clients' audit committees and it was lim ited to tax-related issues, E&Y spokesman Charles Perkins said when Reuters reported on the issue in March.
Washington Council did not solicit votes on legislation for E&Y audit clients, Perkins said.
The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, the watchdog for U.S. auditors, is looking to shore up independence rules after finding numerous instances in which auditors did not dig deeply enough to challenge clients' financial numbers.
The SEC's Kroeker said he was encouraged to see the board tackling the subject.
"Independence is really the bedrock, the foundation of the value that's provided by a third-party audit," he said.
(Reporting by Dena Aubin and David Ingram; additional reporting by Kim Dixon; editing by Kevin Drawbaugh and Matt Driskill)
- EY Set to Replace Deloitte as Tullow Oil’s New External Auditor
- PwC pays £253m to Settle Claims of Professional Negligence
- Deloitte Wins CRH Audit
- EY is expected to Replace KPMG as New Auditor of Aston Martin
- Vodafone Replaces PwC with EY as its New External Auditor
- EY Replaces Deloitte as Capital Group’s New External Auditor
- Need to ‘think small’ on audit standards